What Didn't Fit in the Mummers Episode
This week's episode of The Lost Christmas Podcast told the story of Isaac Mercer, a young Bay Roberts fisherman attacked by masked mummers on December 28th, 1860. Nobody ever stood trial for his death. By March 1862, Newfoundland had first required a license to wear a mask and then banned disguises outright. To keep the episode to about 25 minutes, a lot had to be cut, so here's much of the rest of the story.
Masked visitors were worrying people long before Newfoundland
People in authority have been nervous about masked people at Christmas for more than 600 years. In 1377, about 130 masked men rode to Kennington to entertain the ten-year-old Prince Richard, the future Richard II. They came dressed as knights, an "emperor," a "pope," cardinals and devils. They also brought loaded dice, so the prince would "win" a gold ball, a cup and a ring (Master Mummers).
In 1418, a London proclamation banned going about at night in mummings or disguises with false beards or painted visors. Merrymaking inside your own house was still allowed, and householders had to hang out a lit lantern (British History Online, Riley's Memorials of London). So masks were fine indoors and banned on the street. More than four centuries later, Newfoundland drew almost the same line.
Then in 1511–12, under Henry VIII, Parliament passed "An Act against disguised Persons and wearing of Visours." It got royal assent on March 30th, 1512, and stayed in force until 1863 (Wikipedia: Acts of 1511). England repealed its old anti-mask law just as Newfoundland brought in a new one.
"More than 300 years"? The paperwork says 200
The Mummers Festival describes the custom as more than 300 years old (Mummers Festival). The earliest written records are a newspaper notice from 1812 and Lewis Anspach's history of 1819 (Fraser 2009). The custom is probably older than the paperwork, but "300 years" is a claim rather than a documented fact.
More disguise tricks, and a threat for children
Talking on the in-breath is the classic way to disguise your voice. Memorial University's heritage inventory lists others too: talking with marbles in your mouth, or into a pickle jar (MUN ICH Inventory). The visits also had a scarier side for small children. Parents used to warn them that the mummers would carry them off if they misbehaved (Mummers Festival).
The rest of the court record
The episode covered the first violent case, in Harbour Grace in 1831, where attackers used blubber-dipped swabs, swords and loaded guns. Joy Fraser's survey of the courts goes on to cases in Harbour Grace in 1835, Carbonear in 1838 and St. John's in 1842 and 1850 (Fraser 2009).
The hobby horse turns up in this record too. According to Hakai Magazine, some mummers' hobby horses had rusty nails for teeth (Hakai). In a separate 1861 case in Harbour Grace, a hobby horse was used as a weapon (Fraser 2009). Speaking to CBC, Larry Dohey, an archivist at The Rooms, talked about how disguises could be used to settle grudges (CBC).
Details about Isaac Mercer that rest on one source
On air we called Isaac Mercer "a young fisherman," because the more specific details each come from a single source:
- His age. A caption promoting local historian Mike Flynn's book reportedly gives it as 20 (Flickr/Flynn).
- His marriage. The Globe and Mail reports he had been married about three weeks (Globe and Mail). His wife's name doesn't appear in any of our sources.
- An earlier attack. CBC reports that mummers' whips had cut him the Christmas before (CBC). If that's true, it explains why he wanted his brothers-in-law to walk him home.
The accused, the weapon and a missing coroner's report
Fraser's table gives the ages of three of the accused as 28, 32 and 37 (Fraser 2009). Product of Newfoundland reports that the lead accused, John Dawson, and four others were taken to St. John's (Product of Newfoundland). Dawson was never indicted or tried. The number of attackers isn't settled either. Most local accounts say six, one says five or six, and Atlas Obscura says three (Atlas Obscura).
As for the weapon, the hatchet version comes from the Bay Roberts community history (Community Stories), Product of Newfoundland, The Globe and Mail, and Fraser herself in a 2017 interview on the Living Heritage Podcast. Only one Heritage NL write-up says a hobby horse (Heritage NL), and Fraser's 2009 paper doesn't name a weapon. Our guess, and it is only a guess, is that the hobby horse crept in from that separate 1861 Harbour Grace case.
One more curiosity: a published index of Newfoundland coroner's reports from 1826 to 1878 has no entry for Isaac Mercer (NGB Coroner's Reports).
1861: the most violent election in Newfoundland's history
Four months after the killing, Newfoundland's politics boiled over. Governor Bannerman dismissed Premier John Kent and installed the Conservative Hugh Hoyles. At the election of May 2nd, 1861, one person died in violence at Harbour Main, and the polls at Harbour Grace never opened. In the riot at St. John's, troops fired on the crowd, killing three people and wounding about 20, a priest among them. The Catholic and Anglican bishops took opposite sides. Out of the crisis came the convention that every denomination is included in government (Heritage NL: Election Riots of 1861). No source ties the Mercer killing directly to the election. But Fraser told The Globe and Mail that Conservative papers called it an ambush and Liberal papers called it an accident.
Numbered mummers, a jailbreak and a 1910 poster
While the 1861 Act was being debated, the Legislative Council reportedly considered making mummers wear numbers on their costumes (Product of Newfoundland). After the ban, police patrolled the streets of St. John's. Crowds tried to stop arrests, and at least once people tried to break a mummer out of jail (Globe and Mail). The law was still remembered decades later. A quotation from 1910 mentions a magistrate's poster warning against masking (DCHP-3).
How alive was the "banned" custom?
Very alive. In the 1960s, Memorial University questionnaires on mummering drew more than 1,200 responses (MUN ICH), and a 1965–66 survey covered 343 communities (Tye 2008). The 1969 book Christmas Mumming in Newfoundland included work by Melvin Firestone, John Szwed, James Faris and Louis Chiaramonte (Tye 2008).
The revival's other chapters
The Mummers Troupe, founded in 1972, went on to found RCA Theatre and renovate the LSPU Hall (Heritage NL). There were hard years too. After the 1992 cod moratorium, the custom declined as young people left the outports (Globe and Mail). Simani's "Any Mummers 'Lowed In?" is variously dated to 1982, December 1983 and 1984, which is why we said "early 1980s" (Tye 2008; Wikipedia: Simani). By 2016, twelve other communities ran their own mummers events (Hakai). Ryan Davis was the festival's first coordinator (Atlas Obscura), and Lynn McShane is its current executive director (Globe and Mail).
If you're nearby, the 2026 festival runs from November 20th to December 12th, with the parade on Saturday, December 12th (weather date December 13th) (Mummers Festival).
Four more myths
- "Mummering is purely Irish." It has both English and Irish roots, including English hobby horses and the St George play (Heritage NL).
- "Mummers must stay silent." They talk constantly, in disguised "janney talk" (MUN ICH). The silent "dumb show" idea belongs to medieval mumming (Etymonline).
- "It's an ancient pagan fertility rite." That reading comes from older scholars influenced by James Frazer, and it is now widely criticised. The play texts date from the 1700s (Wikipedia: Mummers' play).
- "Mummering was outlawed after an 1835 attack on editor Henry Winton." This traces to a single 2012 popular article that also gets Winton's newspaper wrong. There's no evidence of any law in 1835 (DCHP-3).
For the full story of Isaac Mercer, the grand jury that never sent anyone to trial, and how the kitchen visit outlived the ban, listen to Season 7, Episode 4 of The Lost Christmas Podcast: Murdered by Mummers.